BladeSystem - General
1748106 Members
4969 Online
108758 Solutions
New Discussion

Dual rank vs. Single rank memory question

 
chuckk281
Trusted Contributor

Dual rank vs. Single rank memory question

Vasyl had some questions regarding memory useage:

 

**************

 

What will be the best choice in terms of performance, 8Gb single rank or dual rank kit for E5-2600? All other parameters are identical.  One DpC, two DpC.

 

*************

 

Serge had some answers:

 

****************

 

We are basically in a transition period as 2Gbit DRAM approach end of life in the next 1-2 years and 4Gbit DRAM have become mainstream.

 

  1. In a one DIMM-per-channel configuration, dual-rank will perform better than single-rank.  In most cases, only memory-intensive applications will notice the difference (like HPC).
  2. In a two DIMM-per-channel configuration, the performance of single and dual-rank will be almost identical (within the accuracy of the measurement).
  3. The single-rank DIMM will be lower power than the dual-rank DIMM.
  4. Long-term, the single-rank DIMM will end up being lower cost and having better availability than the dual-rank DIMM.

 

The main reason we still have the dual-rank DIMM is #1, but I would not recommend it unless the customer’s application requires only one DIMM per channel and is memory intensive.

 

 ****************

 

Other input to this question?