Linux hpasm hpadu scripts call /bin/sh but use bash specific features.

zImage — Wed, 27 Feb 2008 13:46:14 GMT

Hello. I have had problems installing the debian versions of the hp tools on my departments servers. We are running Ubuntu which is probably not supported by HP, but I think this request will be helpful to other customers as well.

The install scripts and runtime tools assume that /bin/sh is a symlink to /bin/bash. On Ubuntu, /bin/sh is /bin/dash. Here is a list of files that contain bashisms but call /bin/sh. You do support debian linux and the Debian policy manual has long mandated that "shell scripts specifying '/bin/sh' as interpreter must only use POSIX features". I request that you change these scripts to either call /bin/bash or to be POSIX compliant in order to make these scripts debian compliant.

Many Thanks

# for i in `find /opt -exec file '{}' ';' | grep Bourne | sed 's/$.*$:.*/\1/'`; do if ( head -n1 $i | grep -q '/sh' ); then checkbashisms $i; fi; done
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/fixperms line 18 (${foo:3[:1]}):
thefile=${rline:0}
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/fixperms line 35 (echo -n/-e):
echo -n '.'
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/fixperms line 48 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $? == 0 ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/fixperms line 65 (echo -n/-e):
echo -n '.'
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 51 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "YES" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 99 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "NO" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 111 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "YES" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 123 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "YES" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 135 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "ADMINISTRATOR" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 147 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "TRUSTBYALL" || $ans == "TRUSTBYNAME" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 180 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "YES" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 193 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $ans == "YES" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 219 (should be 'b = a'):
if [[ $overwrite == "false" ]]; then
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpfdtn.sh line 287 (bash arrays, ${name[0|*|@]}):
for cfile in "${certarray[@]}"; do
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpsmhd.debian line 110 (echo -n/-e):
echo -n "Stopping web server: hpsmhd"
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpsmhd.debian line 125 (echo -n/-e):
echo -n "Restarting web server: hpsmhd"
possible bashism in /opt/hp/support/hpsmhd.debian line 141 (echo -n/-e):
echo -n "Forcing reload of web server: hpsmhd"
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 44 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[1]="a"; xref[2]="b"; xref[3]="c"; xref[4]="d"; xref[5]="e";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 45 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[6]="f"; xref[7]="g"; xref[8]="h"; xref[9]="i"; xref[10]="j";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 46 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[11]="k"; xref[12]="l"; xref[13]="m"; xref[14]="n"; xref[15]="o";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 47 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[16]="p"; xref[17]="q"; xref[18]="r"; xref[19]="s"; xref[20]="t";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 48 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[21]="u"; xref[22]="v"; xref[23]="w"; xref[24]="x"; xref[25]="y";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 49 (bash arrays, H[0]):
xref[26]="z";
possible bashism in /opt/hp/hpadu/HTML/getusb.sh line 68 ('((' should be '$(('):
if((index(VENDOR,"USB FDD") !=0) ||
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/hpasm/etc/rebuild line 51 (echo -n/-e):
echo -e "\t\tCustom Build of hpasm." >> $DISTDIR/SPECS/$SPECFILE
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/hpasm/etc/hpasm line 135 (echo -n/-e):
ARGS=`echo -n $CURRENTARGS | cut -d '|' -f $I`
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/hpasm/etc/hpasm line 149 (echo -n/-e):
TESTSTRING=`echo -n $CURRENTSUBS | fgrep $BASENAME`
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/utils/hpuid_example.sh line 18 (should be 'b = a'):
if [ $1 == "ON" ]
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/utils/hpuid_example.sh line 29 (should be 'b = a'):
if [ $1 == "OFF" ]
possible bashism in /opt/compaq/utils/hpuid_example.sh line 40 (should be 'b = a'):
if [ $1 == "STATUS" ]

Re: Linux hpasm hpadu scripts call /bin/sh but use bash specific features.

Don Vanco - Linux Ninja — Wed, 27 Feb 2008 15:43:24 GMT

As has been pointed out to me on a couple of occasions, this is "peer support" forum, and your request is likely to be better served with a direct submission to HP Support if you expect to get a response from HP.

I know "Linux is technically just kernel" - but the vast majority of distros consider the Linux default shell to be bash, and sym link sh as such.....

While your point has merit, I expect this will be something of "boiling the ocean" for HP to address...

Don

topic Linux hpasm hpadu scripts call /bin/sh but use bash specific features. in Operating System - Linux

Linux hpasm hpadu scripts call /bin/sh but use bash specific features.

Re: Linux hpasm hpadu scripts call /bin/sh but use bash specific features.