HP/H3C 5120-48G-SI

[wberg]

Hi,

We have a bunch of new 5120's running:

Comware Software, Version 5.20, Release 1505P07
Copyright (c) 2010-2011 Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.
HP A5120-48G SI Switch uptime is 0 week, 4 days, 20 hours, 35 minutes

I've irf:ed 4 of those together and added the following configuration on all TP-ports:

interface GigabitEthernet1/0/1
 description ACCESS-PORT
 port link-type hybrid
 undo port hybrid vlan 1
 port hybrid vlan 530 untagged
 port hybrid pvid vlan 530
 voice vlan 612 enable
 stp edged-port enable

When the stacked booted up couple of days ago, everything worked fine. Both computers and telephones. Issuing a "dis vlan 612" showed that all ports were tagged on 612 and "dis vlan 530" showed the same, but untagged.

After ~2days, all IP-phones stopped working, after issuing the same commands again I discovered that "dis vlan 612" now only contains the uplinks. What have happened? I can so nothing to get this solved, adding/removing conf, shutdown/undo shutdown, enable/disable voice, nothing gives, if I reboot the entire stack, everything starts working again.

I also have the same issue on a HP A5120-24G-POE+ SI who is NOT stacked, but running the same software version and configuration.

Issuing a "dis voice vlan state" revils that all ports still seem to have correct configuration and voice should be enabled. Why have the tagged vlan stopped working after 2 days on 2 different switches and setups? Anyone have any experience with this ? Bug? Should I downgrade the software?

[manuel.bitzi]

Sounds strange, but should work.

Please provide more information:

• LLDP konfig
• Voice VLAN konfig
• LLDP neighbors
• Voip phone types
• logs

br

Manuel

[wberg]

Using pretty basic configuration here.

Pretty much lldp enable globally.

I don't see the phones as LLDP neighbors, only the uplink port shows.

No special voice vlan config than about except: undo voice vlan security enable

A dis log reveals nothing upon the time the voice vlan timer expires, vlan is just removed.

We're using Nortel IP Phones 1120E model NTSY03.

dis voice vlan state shows (even after timer expierd)

 GigabitEthernet1/0/1        612         AUTO        6          46

[MichaelM55]

I have never had any problems with LLDP at all on H3C devices.

Give the latest R1512P05 firmware a try: https://h10145.www1.hp.com/downloads/SoftwareReleases.aspx?ProductNumber=JE074A&lang=&cc=&prodSeriesId=

But I don´t think it will help in your case

[wberg]

Yeah, I'll try the new firmware. Got LLDP working as well after resetting the ipphone and configure it from scratch. However it did not help. I can see a LLDP neighbor and the vlan for voice, but when the voice vlan timer runs out, the vlan is removed yet again. The LLDP neighbor is still active thou.

LLDP neighbor-information of port 1[GigabitEthernet1/0/1]:
  Neighbor index   : 1
  Update time      : 0 days,10 hours,0 minutes,25 seconds
  Chassis type     : Network address(ipv4)
  Chassis ID       : 10.200.224.22
  Port ID type     : MAC address
  Port ID          : 0017-65fd-de39
  Port description : Nortel IP Phone
  System description : Nortel IP Telephone 1120E, Firmware:0624C7F
  System capabilities supported : Bridge,Telephone
  System capabilities enabled   : Bridge,Telephone

  Port VLAN ID(PVID): 0

  Port and protocol VLAN ID(PPVID) : 0
  Port and protocol VLAN supported : No
  Port and protocol VLAN enabled   : No

  VLAN name of VLAN 612: Voice

  Protocol ID:

  Protocol ID: Ì

  Auto-negotiation supported : Yes
  Auto-negotiation enabled   : Yes
  OperMau                    : speed(1000)/duplex(Full)

  Power port class          : PD
  PSE power supported       : No
  PSE power enabled         : No
  PSE pairs control ability : No
  Power pairs               : Signal
  Port power classification : Class 3

  Link aggregation supported : No
  Link aggregation enabled   : No
  Aggregation port ID        : 0

  Maximum frame Size: 1522

  Device class: Endpoint Class III

  Media policy type        : Voice
  Unknown Policy           : No
  VLAN tagged              : Yes
  Media policy VlanID      : 612
  Media policy L2 priority : 6
  Media policy Dscp        : 46

  FirmwareRev               : 0624C7F
  Manufacturer name         : Nortel-01
  Model name                : IP Phone 1120E

  PoE PD power source       : Unknown
  Port PD Priority          : High
  Port available power value: 9.6(w)

[wberg]

Since noone seem to have any ideas I opened a HP TAC case. The engineer didn't know what was wrong, and they should try my configuration in the lab so see if they can reproduce it. If they can, this might be a bug, I'll keep you all posted.

I also figured out a temporary workaround to this problem, if I add the oui of some phones manually they work. But like I said earlier, the customer have tons of different oui's, so this don't scale at all.

 voice vlan mac-address 0017-6500-0000 mask ffff-ff00-0000 description Nortel

Which is kinda stupid, since then the "undo voice vlan security enable" command have no function, the main idea and goal was to turn off the security check for a mac and just let whom ever talk... But it's a workaround, hopefully the TAC will get back to me with something useful.

[jguse]

Hello,

How is the case with support progressing? I thought I'd provide a bit of input on your issue, even if it is late.

First of all, it looks like you wish to use LLDP in order to place the phones into the Voice VLAN automatically. However judging by the configuration you showed, this is not configured properly.

You can put the ports with phones into the voice vlan manually, as you have done with "voice vlan 612 enable", which will be subject to the voice VLAN aging timer (24h by default on Comware 5), and cause the switch to discard the voice VLAN after the timer expires. This is as designed in Comware 5 (was a bit different with CW3), and for deployments with older phones that do not support LLDP.

Otherwise you should use LLDP detection instead. This is configured with the command "lldp voice-vlan 612" instead.

Example config for you...

SYSTEM VIEW:

lldp enable

lldp compliance cdp

PORT VIEW:

port link-type hybrid

undo port hybrid vlan 1
port hybrid vlan 530 untagged

port hybrid vlan 612 tagged
port hybrid pvid vlan 530
undo voice vlan 612 enable

poe enable

lldp voice-vlan 612

lldp compliance admin-status cdp txrx
stp edged-port enable

I bolded the parts that should be changed.

Hope that helps you out. If you try to configure this and it still doesn't work, please provide your new configuration. Thanks!

[Pradeep225]

Hi ,

im facing one that is, i ve applied below setting but it taking data vlan on both device as IP phon shoud b pick d vocie vlan

sharing config with you for your info, and seeking yuor help in this regards

 HP A5120-24G-POE+ SI Switch

interface GigabitEthernet1/0/7
 port link-type hybrid
 undo port hybrid vlan 1
 port hybrid vlan 231 tagged      (Voice)
 port hybrid vlan 2 untagged  (Data)
 port hybrid pvid vlan 2
 poe enable

please help me,.......

Thanks

Pradeep