Simpler Navigation coming for Servers and Operating Systems
Coming soon: a much simpler Servers and Operating Systems section of the Community. We will combine many of the older boards, and you won't have to click through so many levels to get at the information you need. If you are looking for an older board and do not find it, check the consolidated boards, as the posts are still there.
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

What to buy

SOLVED
Go to solution
Paula J Frazer-Campbell
Honored Contributor

What to buy

Hi
I want to buy a "Play" machine for myself and have a choice of the following - prices about the same.

Having never worked on these machines which would be the best?


HP9000, D250, 1 x 160mhz, 2 x 4Gb, 576mb

or

HP9000, K210, 2 x 120mhz, 4 x 2Gb, 256mb


Paula
If you can spell SysAdmin then you is one - anon
11 REPLIES
Eugen Cocalea
Respected Contributor

Re: What to buy

Hi,

I would buy the second.

Reasons:
1. You can test single-processor behaviour on a dual-processor machine, but not the other way.
2. You can test more soft-RAID configurations on 4 hdds than on 2 (given the same amount of space)
3. Less memory is not really a disadvantage.

E.
To Live Is To Learn
Santosh Nair_1
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

I would go for the K box...they seem to be more flexible than the D boxes. Also, you should get more performance out the of K box with two processors than with a D box with one processor. The only limiting factor is the memory...but if you'd not planning on anything memory intensive, i.e. databases, you should be okay with the K box. Also, you can get K memory from Kingstons for a fraction of the price you'd pay to HP...since this is a play machine, it should be okay.

-Santosh
Life is what's happening while you're busy making other plans
A. Clay Stephenson
Acclaimed Contributor

Re: What to buy

Hi Paula:

Given those two choices, I would go for the D-box. If you have a D-250 that is actually a PA-7200 processor running at 100Mhz; if it's truly a 160Mhz processor, it's a D270 running a PA-8000. That's even better because with that you can upgrade to 11.11 64-bit if you remove any EISA cards. You could then have a box on which you could test both 32-bit and 64-bit versions of all the operating systems.

I also like the greater amount of memory in the D-box.

My 3 cents, Clay
If it ain't broke, I can fix that.
Bill McNAMARA_1
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

I'd get the D too..

Later,
Bill
It works for me (tm)
Volker Borowski
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

Paula,

if there is a chance for the 64-bit option, I would follow Clays suggestion.
In addition, if you want to upgrade RAM, I think you can put standard PC-RAMs into a D, but not into a K.

Volker
Victor BERRIDGE
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

Hi Paula,
If the D has a PA8000 processor AND the hot swap option (your 4 Gb would be hot swap FWD-SCSI...)
I would definiltely go for it because the power requirement and spare parts would be less compared to the Kclass
I just checked on on D230, ther is a PA7000 running at 160 Mhz:
# echo itick_per_usec/D|adb -k /stand/vmunix /dev/kmem
itick_per_usec:
itick_per_usec: 160
Module Revision
------ --------
System Board 0
Processor Board 0
PA-7300LC CPU 8
Firmware 12


All the best

Victor
John Bolene
Honored Contributor
Solution

Re: What to buy

Depending on where you have to install this box, I would get the D also as it is much smaller and takes less electricity to run.

The D can hold 5 internal drives at 9 or 18G, easy to add storage.

It has a faster CPU, can run 64 bit code, and although it is not 2 processor now, has the potential to be 2 processor.

My 2 coppers.
It is always a good day when you are launching rockets! http://tripolioklahoma.org, Mostly Missiles http://mostlymissiles.com
Thierry Poels_1
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

hi,

get them both, then you can play around with MC/ServiceGuard, DNS, ... ;-)

The typical answer is "It depends", they both have their advantages.

regards,
Thierry
All unix flavours are exactly the same . . . . . . . . . . for end users anyway.
Paula J Frazer-Campbell
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

Thanks to all

I have gone for the D Class,

BTW

John's answer was not better that everyone else???s I just wanted the magic rabbit to appear.


LOL

Paula


If you can spell SysAdmin then you is one - anon
Wodisch
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

Hello Paula,

I would go for D-class, too, as you have the chance of doing all that funny testing by *unplugging* disks while running!
So you could test your root-disk-mirroring,
which I believe is pretty useful.
The second processor will not do you so much good for AFAIK you cannot disable it on D or K class boxes (no GSP) and its power is not needed for "playing".
More RAM is useful all the time, especially with HPUX11i, with Ignite/UX, you could even try the RAMdisk-driver :-)

Just my $0.001,
Wodisch
Carlos Fernandez Riera
Honored Contributor

Re: What to buy

I agree Jonh. D`s are lighter than Ks, and to play .. :).

Jokes out. I guess you plan to buy a remarked box. If you must be able to run 10.20, then D. But if you dont need 10.20 check the posibility of A class from remarketing.

Like a L but smallest.
unsupported