SOLVED
@Tom-2019 wrote:On the other side is a HP Aruba 2530:
VLAN ID = 1, for LAN
VLAN ID = 20, for VoIPPort 1 is a Trunk (connected to port 34 HPE 1950)
Group = Trk1
Typ = Trunk
The problem is you used an aggregated links logical interface "Trk1" (which member ports?)...that's wrong...you misunderstood the term "trunk" used on ArubaOS-Switch based Switch series (which doesn't mean a port carrying multiple VLAN Ids like on Comware based Switches like the HPE OfficeConnect 1950...).
Retry by using a single physical interface and tag it that way:
config
interface ethernet X untagged vlan 1
interface ethernet X tagged vlan 20
vlan 20
voice
exit
write memory
and...
@Tom-2019 wrote:
Port 2-10 are a VoIP Devices, VLAN Port Assignment:
VLAN 0010 = no
VLAN 0020 = UntaggedThese devices are working fine.
generally VoIP devices (VoIP Phones) are connected to ports which are tagged member of Voice VLAN...so
config
vlan 20
tagged 2-15
exit
and
vlan 1
untagged 2-15
exit
write memory
I'm not an HPE Employee
@Tom-2019 wrote: Only interface 1 (uplink) is member of trk1 on the 2530.
Hi Tom.
That's the reason I wrote you that...if you're going to use ONLY one physical interface for inter-linking your two Switches then you must not use any Ports Aggregation with that interface on Aruba 2530 side...simply because there isn't a matching Ports Aggregation on the peer 1950. So one interface on HPE 1950 <-- uplink --> one interface on Aruba 2530. Very simple (as is and as you already wired). Different is if you PLAN to have a Ports Aggregation but you actually just connect both peers with one cable (but you plan to add another one - or more ones - at later time)...but I thing that wasn't your purpose.
@Tom-2019 wrote: If I delete trk1 now, I will lose connection to the switch.
That's absolutely normal...you're deleting a logical interface with its physical member interface (port 34 of Aruba 2530)...IMHO you should connect directly to Aruba 2530 and do the change: remove Trk1 and change tagging of port 34 (which returns to be untagged in VLAN id 1) to match what is on interface 1 on HPE 1950.
@Tom-2019 wrote:
The vlan config on the 1950 is:
interface GigabitEthernet1/0/1
port access vlan 20
poe enable
#interface GigabitEthernet1/0/2
poe enable
#interface GigabitEthernet1/0/3
port access vlan 20
poe enable
#interface GigabitEthernet1/0/4
poe enable
#interface GigabitEthernet1/0/5
port access vlan 20
poe enable
#interface GigabitEthernet1/0/6
poe enable
#
...interface GigabitEthernet1/0/34
port link-type trunk
port trunk permit vlan 1 20
poe enable
#I think this means tagged ports for the vlan20 (voice) on interface 1/0/1; 1/0/3; 1/0/5.
No...on HPE OfficeConnect 1950 an interface with port access set to a particular VLAN id means that that interface is untagged on that particular VLAN id...which is 20 (and when it is not specified...default wins...so the interface is Untagged member of VLAN id 1)...so 1/0/1, 1/0/3 and 1/0/5 are Untagged member of VLAN id 20, defaulted interface are instead Untagged member of VLAN id 1. Uplink interface 1/0/34 is Untagged member of VLAN id 1 and Tagged member of VLAN id 20...and, if this is your desired config, the port on Aruba 2530 should match that.
@Tom-2019 wrote:
The current vlan config on the 2530 is:
trunk 1 trk1 trunk
vlan 1
name "VLAN 0001"
no untagged 2-4,6-28
untagged 5
tagged Trk1
no ip address
exitvlan 20
name "VLAN 0020 VOIP"
untagged 2-4,6-28
tagged Trk1
ip address 10.1.1.2 255.255.255.0
exitspanning-tree Trk1 priority 4
interface 1 (current trk1) uplink.
interface 5 => vlan001.
interface 2-4,6-28 vlan0020
Does the config match to the 1950? I think uplink interface 1 should be tagged in both vlans.
Considering that Aruba 2530 shows this:
trunk 1 trk1 trunk
vlan 1
name "VLAN 0001"
no untagged 2-4,6-28
untagged 5
tagged Trk1
no ip address
exit
vlan 20
name "VLAN 0020 VOIP"
untagged 2-4,6-28
tagged Trk1
ip address 10.1.1.2 255.255.255.0
exit
spanning-tree Trk1 priority 4
You should start by deleting trk1 logical interface (you must be on the Aruba 2530 to do that without losing connection) and then set that port 1 is an Untagged member of VLAN id 1 and concurrently a Tagged member of VLAN id 20, do that with these two commands:
interface ethernet 1 untagged vlan 1
interface ethernet 1 tagged vlan 20
Check result with show vlan port 1 detail command.
From what you reported ports' ranges 2-4 and 6-28 are ONLY tagged member (no untagged on VLAN 1) Untagged members of VLAN id 20...I don't know if this is wanted...generally, as written, ports are Tagged members of a Voice VLAN and Untagged members of a User dedicated VLAN id when the scenario is PC <---> VoIP Terminal <---> Switch Port scenario (but here it seems you have PC <---> Switch Port and VoIP Terminal <---> Switch Port...) in any case if I were you I will reconfigure to use Voice VLAN tagged other than Untagged on access ports...and do the same on HPE OfficeConnect 1950 (in this case access ports will become of type trunk because they will carry a VLAN id - the Voice one - tagged).
Port 5 is the only one port which is currently Untagged member of VLAN id 1 and hasn't other tagging.
I'm not an HPE Employee
I'm not an HPE Employee