Trunk form procurve 2910al to Extreme 450e

[brianclick3x]

Hey Vince,

Im back and mad ...

So I had to update all my Procurve Switches to the latest firmware, everything seemed to go fine and I rebooted them all.

I have a stack of 3.

However after doing so suddenly the wireless stopped workin, I though that this might just be that the extreme switch neede to be rebooted, however after rebooting twice no dice.

From a laptop connected to the Extreme switch i could once again ping all the way to the firewall, but not out past the firewall.

none of the settings seemed to change since the update of the procurev switches.

The commander switch that i have the extreme plugged into via port 21 still showed vlan2 with ip 192.168.3.11 and still showed the port tagged.

The extreme showed vlan2 with port 21 tagged.

I self assigned the laptop with ip 192.168.3.244 -

So I thought i would trash the wireless vlan on both devices and start again.

After rebuilding them on both, i can no longer ping from the Extreme switch to the HP switch at 192.168.3.11

however from the laptop I can ping all the way to the firewall but still not out.

Any ideas?

thanks

[brianclick3x]

Hey so an update

Its driving me bananas

So to verify that there wasnt anything funky on the extreme i did a full factory reboot

The only configuration i did on that switch was

Add vlan wireless

tag vlan wireless 2

add port 21 tagged

add port 1-16 untagged

tagged port 21 on default vlan 1

didnt add any routes or enable ipforwarding.

From a laptop plugged into the switch in port 1 - I can ping to firewall 199.95.137.1/HP switch 199.95.137.13/VLAN2 on hp switch 192.168.3.11

However I cannot ping past the firewall.

Firewall settings remain the same which has a static route to the HP switch

HP settings

trashed the origonal vlan 2

re added the vlan with port 21 tagged

see config below

ip default-gateway 199.95.137.1
ip route 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 199.95.135.1
ip routing

interface 21
   name "EXTREME ULINK"
   exit

vlan 1
   name "DEFAULT_VLAN"
   untagged 22-24,33-48,A1,Trk1,Trk3,Trk6-Trk7
   tagged 21
   ip address 199.95.137.13 255.255.255.0
   exit
vlan 2
   name "wireless"
   tagged 21
   ip address 192.168.3.11 255.255.255.0
   exit
no autorun

[brianclick3x]

Could it possibly be that i need to turn the extreme off.
Reboot the main switch, reboot the firewall and then plug in the extreme? could something be hung up from when i rebooted the main switch earlier?

[brianclick3x]

After rebooting HP switch and its 2 stacked switches, unable to get out from firewall on extreme switch

on vlan2 wireless,didnt have extreme switch off when i rebooted the main switch.

Then when we realised couldnt get out on the wireless vlan Tried rebooting Extreme several times still nothing

Reset Extreme to factory settings and setup vlan 2 again

deleted vlan 2 from HP switch and then readded it.

Still cannot get out - see pingable addresses below

Only thing that i havnt tried since rebuilding the vlans on both switches is rebooting the main HP switch or rebooting firewall.

here is the current setup

Firewall Sonicwall NSA3500 --  199.95.137.1 - connected to port on HP switch

Firewall  --  199.95.137.1

Address Object -

Name -HPSWITCH-

ZoneAssignment-LAN-

Type-Host-

IP 199.95.137.13

Name VLAN WIRELESS

ZoneAssignments LAN

TYPE NETWORK

NETWORK 192.168.3.0

NETMASK 255.255.255.0

ROUTING

Route Policies -

Source - ANY -

Destination VLAN WIRELESS -

SERVIE ANY -

GATEWAY HP SWITCH -

INTERFACE X0

Port 24 to firewall

HP Procurve 2910al switch

Gateway default 199.95.138.1

Ip forwarding

Ip route 0.0.0.0 - 0.0.0.0 - 199.95.138.1

Vlan 1 -- default ---  HP switch ip 199.95.137.13

Tagged port 21

Vlan2 -- wireless

192.168.3.11

Tagged port 21

PORT 21 from HP to PORT 21 Extreme 

Extreme 450e Switch

Vlan1 default

Tagged port 21

Vlan2 wireless

Tagged port 21

Untagged port 1-16

No ipforwarding

No iproutes

Laptop assigned ip 192.168.3.244

255.255.255.0

192.168.3.11

Ping Results

From Laptop

Can ping 192.168.3.11

Can ping 199.95.137.13

Can ping 199.95.137.1

Cannot ping past firewall

From firewall

Can ping 192.168.3.11

Can ping 192.168.3.244

From Extreme

Cannot ping most things

From HP can ping all the way outside firewall

any help appreciated

[brianclick3x]

Additional Info from the HP

IP Route Entries

Destination Gateway VLAN Type Sub-Type Metric Dist.
------------------ --------------- ---- --------- ---------- ---------- -----
127.0.0.0/8                 reject                         static 0 0
127.0.0.1/32              lo0                              connected 1 0
156.153.78.192/27                                   connected 1 0
192.168.3.0/24        wireless 2               connected 1 0
199.95.137.0/24     DEFAULT_VLAN 1 connected 1 0